Do I take the lead or do I let my wife lead on this?
My wife and I got married way too soon. We got married after knowing eachother for 5 months, and had a baby right away. We didn’t move in with one another until after the wedding. The relationship went downhill from the wedding ceremony. We separated 7 months into the marriage and filed for divorce a few months later.
During the time we lived together it was horrible. I moved into her house, since it was bigger and I took a job closer to her home with the plan that the potential increase in income would allow her to be a stay at home mom. I promised that she could stay home in 3 years maximum and I would handle the finances, because she is horrible with money and she worries about money a lot. She’s a teacher and gets paid once a month, and I’m a financial advisor…so budgeting, saving, and money management are my strong suits.
Fast forward to today…we are approaching or 3 year anniversary…the divorce has been put on hold and we have been working on the relationship for about 10 months now. I found that she intentionally delayed and stalled the divorce because she had second thoughts from the day she filed.
To make a long story short I have learned that this woman that I thought I married who comes off as a strong and independant single mother is a sensitive and scared woman who is afraid of being alone & realizes that her indepedance for so long causes her to push people away even when she isn’t trying, because she comes across as selfish…mainly because she’s so use to taking care of herself and her child (now children) by herself with the assistance of her parents at times.
Having taken the time to know this woman under the surface I realize that she NEEDS me to be strong and even domineering. I’m more of the let’s make decisions together kind of man, but I am learning that she prefers to be directed and told…even though she comes across as if she’s doing things her way. This includes everything from initiating sex to deciding what to eat for dinner. She expects me to take charge and/or make decisions.
OKAY…NOW THAT YOU HAVE THE BACKGROUND HERE IS THE ISSUE.
I am back living in my home which is 85 miles away from my new job. I can make a significant income at my new job, but it may take a year or two to get to the 6 figure mark. For now I have a base salary which is half her income.
Now we are at the stage of our reconciliation where we’re talking in a round about way about how much we hate being apart at night, however she won’t come right out and ask me to move back in and I don’t think that I should ask her if I can move back in.
I’m struggling financially and I have my own mortgage and bills to pay, but at the same time this 85 mile commute is killing me…not to mention 2 nights a week I have graduate school until 10pm and I have to wake up at 4:30AM to beat traffic.
I’m going to eventually have to get a place closer to my job. If I rent out my house rents in the area are less than half my mortgage so I’ll only be able to afford a dump in LA…and I have 50% custody of our child and also two older children that I spend a lot of time with.
Moving back in with my wife will help our relationship develop faster, because right now we visit for a few hours or overnight and I go back home. If I moved in I wouldn’t be able to significantly help with any expenses until I start making commissions on my job and get back on my feet financially.
However, there is this 800 pound gorilla in the corner whenever I come over because I am leaving in the morning…or that night. When I come over and spend a day or evening she is so relieved because I watch the kids while she does the things she needs to do…or WANTS to do such as rest or hobbies. The kids are calmer and better behaved when I’m there. I believe in strict bedtimes, so she gets a lot of time to herself when I’m over.
We’ve talked about the "details" of our marriage which will have to be worked out in order for this to last…and the only real detail is living together. She has expressed wanting to figure out the "details", but has not come out and said she wants me to move back in.
Another issue is when I did live with her she made my life a living hell. So much so that I vowed to never live in another woman’s house. Even before we split up I knew that in order for me to feel comfortable in our marriage we would have to have our own house together. However right now with the real estate market in Southern California us buying a house together is not in the question. An apartment in LA would cost more than either of our mortgages.
I feel that if I take the lead and say I want to move in that she would go along, but I don’t feel it is my place to ask. I was the one that left initially; however she admits to created a situation to make me want to leave.
This is so complicated, can you please offer some advice. By the way…while going to counseling is probably a good ans
While going to counseling may be a good answer it is not an option right now for various reasons.
5 Responses
John P D
02 Feb 2010
jimrich
02 Feb 2010
LOL…..if you want to move back in………..say so!
Seems like you are both RUINING YOUR KID’S LIVES by being stubborn, childish and defensive…..just to mention a few things.
YOUR KIDS NEED some good, reliable, loving parents before they too develope (are given) your bad behaviors and bad habits….it’s probably already happened.
Get some counseling and/or
study up on good relationship skills and learn how to make a good life FOR YOUR CHILDREN’S SAKE!!!!!
Johnny
02 Feb 2010
both of you have to share the responsibilities together . sit together and decide
RAVEN
02 Feb 2010
wow, stuck between a rock and a hard place huh?
moving back in would be a mistake
you have lots to assess and find out before you do
is she just wanting "someone" to be there or does she really love you? will she treat you badly again? and is she looking for someone to make the chidren behave better and have a nanny for them?
what benefit would YOU get from moving back in?
you are in this situation out of circumstance, and whilst you have a duty of care to your children, i’m afraid you dont to your wife, you cannot help someone who wont help themselves
if i were you, i would be moving nearer your job and spending what time you can at your wifes house with your children, ask if you can stay overnight,, spare room, sofa, or bunk in with one of the children, this will make travelling less
you have to concentrate on making a career for yourself, you cannot take care of your children without one, meantime, you can see whether your relationship stands the test of time and works this time, instead of plummeting right in, it will confuse the children if it all goes pear shaped again
you have some tough choices to make, but you have to do something sooner rather than later, travelling etc the way you do? you will burn out, coupled with all the stress, you will be in no fit state to do anything
i hope you find an answer
good luck
Anja H
02 Feb 2010
It sounds like you would like her to take a stance in things, tell you her honest opinion, feelings, thoughts – and she is not doing that.
As her what she wants. Regardless of the consequences she might fear. If she can not talk to you face to face, because she wonders what you will say, she could write those things down. Where does she see you, her, the two of you within the next 3 month ?
Tell her, that you would like to hear her opinion on the situation, what she wants and her thoughts on how you both will get there.
It seems she is afraid to stand up for herself, make a decision and then deal with the consequences. It also seems she has a feeling of low self-worth, or a previous bad experience.
I mean, to ask you what you want to eat here and there is ok – but not being able to decide that ever and just put the food on the table is a little strange.
You say, that you knew better than to move into a woman’s house. I am not sure, why this is a big deal. However, if one moves in with another, the one who owns the house need to make space for the partners furniture, let them be part of decoration and so forth – otherwise the other person will never feel at home there.
Hope the above gives you some ideas and help.
Good luck to you.


too complicated for me. my initial reaction would be for you to ask/beg to move back in. long distance relationships do not work